Fan-Cast: Batman solo!

It’s been reported by Deadline that Ben Affleck and Geoff Johns will co-write the Batman solo, supposedly titled The Batman. Affleck is also reported to be directing his solo film rumored for a 2018 release. So I decided to do some fan-casting for this solo film, although I don’t know what story line/characters it would involve. A lot of fans are hoping for a Under the Hood or Court of Owls film, but I guess we’ll see…

Confirmed cast for the solo film includes Affleck, Jeremy Irons, JK Simmons, and newcomer Joe Manganiello as Deathstroke.

Obviously, Batman has already been cast so no need to fan-cast him along with the Joker (Jared Leto), Harley Quinn (Margot Robbie), Alfred (Jeremy Irons), Commissioner Gordon (JK Simmons) and the Suicide Squad characters. So far it looks like Bruce has worked with at least Dick and Jason (who appears to be killed by the Joker in the DCCU). I think I will add on to this fan-cast over time, so let me know who you want to see added!



BARBARA GORDON (Batgirl/Oracle)

batgirl barbara gordon

Allison W, Anna K, Ashley G, Daisy R, Emma S, Emma W, Jane L, Lily J, Marie A, Mary EW, Olivia C, Riley K, Rose L, Shailene W, Willa F, Zoey D.

Now that it’s been confirmed Jena Malone is NOT Barbara Gordon, we can fan cast her! Now Affleck’s Batman has been Batman for awhile, but I don’t know if he’s encountered Barbara yet. Given Commissioner Gordon’s casting and what sounds like a dark past for Bruce, I’d expect Barbara to make an appearance at some point, whether she’s already Batgirl or Oracle. Batman has had a history however with the Joker so it’s possible she’s already Oracle. If the Birds of Prey rumors are true, though, it’d be better to see Babs go from Batgirl to Oracle. But we’ll see.

BATWOMAN (Katherine “Kate” Kane)

batwoman kate kane

Alexandra B, Alexandra D, Allison W, Anna K, Emily B, Emmy R, Evan RW, Ingrid BB, Jessica C, Olivia W, Rachel N, Riley K.

So I don’t know if this is Jena Malone’s mystery role or not, I think her role is Barbara, but we’ll see in the extended edition of Batman v Superman. Anyways, I varied on age a bit for this fan-cast and of course looked at fan suggestions as well. I think anyone (who can act of course) could be Kate, but we’ll see!

BLACK MASK (Roman Sionis)

black mask

Alexander S, Clive O, Eric B, Jason S, Joaquin P, Jon H, Joseph F, Mark S, Matthew G, Matthew M, Richard A, Rufus S, Timothy O, Viggo M, Wes B, Zachary Q.

We haven’t seen Black Mask in live-action yet and he’d be an interesting character to bring to the DCEU. I don’t know if/when WB would introduce the character, however. And as soon as I put this up, David Ayer tweets Black Mask, which calls to question if he will then appear in the Gotham City Sirens film.

CASSANDRA CAIN (Batgirl/Black Bat)

Probably the youngest of the Batgirls, Cassandra may not appear for awhile (or ever) in the DC movie universe. For now, I won’t fan-cast her.

CATWOMAN (Selina Kyle)


Berenice M, Carla G, Charlize T, Diane K, Elsa P, Emily B, Eva G, Jordana B, Karla S, Kate B, Lena H, Milla J, Olga K, Olivia W, Paula P, Sarah S.

Given that they decided to go with an older Batman in the DCCU, there’s a possibility Catwoman would be older as well. So I had a huge age range in possible choices and tried my best to narrow it down. If I am missing anyone, let me know. If not, vote in the poll who you would pick!

*Update – Amber Heard has been removed due to her casting as Mera in Justice League and Aquaman.


For now, I’m leaving off fan-casting for Damian as I don’t know how likely he’ll show up in the DCEU.

DEATHSTROKE (Slade Wilson)

*UPDATE* Joe Manganiello confirmed to be Deathstroke in the DCEU!

DICK GRAYSON (Nightwing)

dick grayson nightwing

Adam G, Armie H, Bob M, Brant D, Daniel R, Daniel S, Douglas B, Drew R, Dylan OB, Finn W, Garrett H, Kevin Z, Logan L, Penn B, Steven RM.

The reason I left him simply Dick Grayson is because I don’t know what alter ego we could see him as in the DCEU. There’s a lot of rumors surrounding the Robins and one is that Dick will already be Nightwing and has parted ways from Bruce. So I’m fan casting for Nightwing/Dick…hopefully that is true. UPDATE – Nightwing will get his own solo film which confirms the rumors of where he’s at in the DCEU…Let’s hope to hear casting soon!

*UPDATE – Tyler Hoechlin has been removed due to his casting in CW’s Supergirl as Superman. Ben Barnes has been removed due to his casting in The Punisher.*


two face harvey dent

Aidan T, Armie H, Ethan H, Eric B, Joel E, Jonathan RM, Jon H, Joseph F, Jude L, Keanu R, Leonardo D, Kevin M, Martin W, Matthew M, Richard A, Timothy O.

Maybe we will see the evolution of Two-Face as well in the DCCU? All we really know is that Batman has been fighting crime for a while now. Who knows how many villains he has already taken down, (asides the ones in Arkham in Suicide Squad, who he supposedly took down).



Aiysha H, Alexis K, Ana DA, Ashley G, Astrid BF, Courtney E, Daisy R, Emmy R, Genesis R, Julia V, Marie A, Mary EW, Meghan O, Olivia W, Phoebe T, Rooney M.

I already had a Huntress fan-cast from Birds of Prey, so I just used the same one since I figured it’d work in whichever movie she’s introduced.

*UPDATE – Serinda Swan removed due to casting in Inhumans.*

JASON TODD (Red Hood?)

Jason Todd Red Hood

Alexander L, Alex P, Daniel S, Dominic S, Douglas B, Drew R, Edward H, Glenn P, Harry L, Jake A, Kit H, Jeremy S, Liam H, Nolan GF, Taron E, William M.

Jason is confirmed to be the dead Robin of cinematic universe (as it should be). Whether we see him become Red Hood is the big question. I’d like to think Affleck will incorporate him in his solo film but we’ll have to wait and see…

POISON IVY (Pamela Isley)

poison ivy

Alexandra B, Amanda R, Blake L, Bryce DH, Carice VH, Eva G, Evan RW, Haley B, Holland R, Imogen P, Jane L, Jessica C, Natalie D, Olivia W, Riley K, Sarah G.

I found a lot of fan-cast ideas from fans and included a few of my own. I am missing actresses, most likely, because I feel that the casting of Poison Ivy is the most versatile. As long as the actress can act and doesn’t mind wearing a wig/dying her hair, she could work. Let me know who you would pick!

*Update – Amber Heard has been removed due to her casting as Mera in Justice League and Aquaman!


ras al ghul

Ashraf B, Billy Z, Daniel DL, Ghassan M, Ian AD, Jason I, Jay A, Joaquin P, Keanu R, Ken W, Oded F, Richard A, Rufus S, Sacha BC, Shaun T, Viggo M.

It was definitely difficult finding suitable actors for this role…I really hope there isn’t another white actor portraying the character (although both previous actors were fine). I did look for other’s fan cast ideas to incorporate with any of my own. Let me know your pick!

*UPDATE – Alexander Siddig removed due to casting as Ra’s Al Ghul (yes!) in Gotham (boo).*



Andrew S, Casey A, Domhnall G, Eddie R, Jay B, Jim P, Johnny D, Jude L, Martin W, Matthew G, Matthew GG, Neil PH.

There’s a bit of a tease/easter egg in Batman v Superman of Riddler, and Snyder revealed he also originally had plans to introduce him in the film. But to save time, he didn’t (thankfully). So instead, we can fan-cast him for the solo! Or whenever he pops up I guess…


Abbie C, Alexandra B, Alice E, Brittany S, Charlize T, Charlotte S,

Abbie C, Alexandra B, Alice E, Ali L, Brittany S, Charlize T, Charlotte S, Diane K, Kate B, Katheryn W, Malin A, Michelle W, Piper P, Rosamund P, Serinda S, Sienna M.

Given that this Batman is older than what we’ve been introduced to before, I don’t know the possibility of Silver showing up in this universe. She may be someone from Bruce’s past as well. We’ll see I guess!

STEPHANIE BROWN (Batgirl/Robin/Spoiler)

stephanie brown spoiler

Annasophia R, Brighton R, Chloe M, Dove C, Elle F, Halston S, Kiernan S, Maika M, Nicola P, Odeya R, Peyton L, Saoirse R, Skyler S, Stefanie S, Taissa F.

Batman has so many Robins/Batgirls/etc and I’m not sure if we’ll see all of them in the DC movie universe. Perhaps a few might have to go to the TV universe for any live-action attempt. I’ll fan-cast Stephanie anyways, though. If she does get a chance at live-action, I think she should stick to being called Spoiler, to differentiate from others and not further confuse non-CB readers. She’ll probably one of the youngest as well.

*UPDATE – Olivia Holt removed due to casting in Cloak & Dagger. Virginia Gardner has been removed due to casting in Marvel’s Runaways.*


Talia Al Ghul

Aiysha H, Berenice M, Camilla B, Freida P, Gemma A, Jordana B, Moran A, Noomi R, Odette A, Olga K, Priyanka C, Tatiana M

Finding actresses was a bit difficult for Talia, even when I looked for fans’ suggestions. Let me know though who you would pick!


tim drake robin

Asa B, Ashton M, Boo Boo S, Brandon SH, Dylan OB, Josh H, Logan L, Nick R, Ryan P, Sterling B, Timothee C, Tyler P.

Now if Affleck does bring back the Robins into the DCEU, it makes sense to go with Tim next, given that in the comics he is the 3rd person to don the name. Thanks to BvS, we see the events that happened with Jason Todd had already occurred, and we can assume Dick Grayson had also been around before. If we see either of the two in the DCEU, it’ll likely be as Red Hood and Nightwing. So for Tim, we don’t want to fan-cast too old or too young (because we still have Damian Wayne to think of). I tried to vary in the FC with fan suggestions and my own. Note – Ryan Potter has been vying for the role and even went so far as to make a campaign-like video.

“Like Tim said, Batman needs a Robin.”


Vicki Vale

Amanda R, Carla G, Charlotte S, Jamie K, Jennifer M, Malin A, Michelle W, Olivia W, Rachel B, Rachel N, Rebecca F, Sarah L, Serinda S, Sophia B, Tamsin E.

Now I don’t know the likeliness of Vicki appearing in the DCCU, but I am really trying to include as many characters from the Batman universe into this fan-cast. Let me know who you’d pick (and as always, if I’m missing someone).

*UPDATE – Lauren Cohan removed due to her casting as Martha Wayne in Batman v Superman. Brie Larson has been removed due to her casting as Captain Marvel.*



As of Jan 3, 2017 Emma Stone for Batgirl/Barbara Gordon, Alexandra Breckenridge for Batwoman, Steven R McQueen for Nightwing, Daisy Ridley for Huntress, Kate Beckinsale for Catwoman, Taron Egerton for Red Hood/Jason Todd, Chloe Moretz for Stephanie Brown/Spoiler, Jessicas Chastain for Poison Ivy, Ryan Potter for Tim Drake/Robin, Alice Eve for Silver St Cloud, Gemma Arterton for Talia Al Ghul, Daniel Day Lewis for Ra’s Al Ghul, Amanda Righetti for Vicki Vale, Jon Hamm for Two Face, Neil Patrick Harris for The Riddler.

My top-picks:


Jane Levy as Barbara Gordon/Batgirl, Evan Rachel Wood as Batwoman/Kate Kane, Kate Beckinsale as Catwoman, Finn Wittrock as Dick Grayson/Nightwing, Astrid Berges-Frisby as Huntress, Taron Egerton as Jason Todd/Red Hood, Haley Bennett as Poison Ivy, Alexander Siddig as Ra’s Al Ghul, Andrew Scott as The Riddler, Piper Pepadou as Silver St Cloud, Annasophia Robb as Stephanie Brown/Spoiler, Moran Atias as Talia Al Ghul, Ryan Potter as Tim Drake/Robin, Martin Wallstrom as Two-Face/Harvey Dent, Sophia Bush as Vicki Vale.


39 thoughts on “Fan-Cast: Batman solo!

  1. i love your choices for nightwing , spoiler , jason todd better than people choices , and glad most people are suggesting my pick for Tim Drake so i will explain why he is one of the best picks of Tim Drake after Logan Lerman of course , Tim became robin at 14 years old maybe in this Bat universe they will age him to a 17 years old Tim but we will see , Colin Ford is 19 years old he is one of the actors that i want in the DCEU or the MCU , he is very versatile playing with such big names like Matt Damon , Dean Norris and Jason Bateman so playing with Ben Affleck won’t be a problem the reason why he could rock as Tim Drake is his role as Supernatural as young Sam Winshester Sam is a mature teenager and also hiding his Emotions and dealing with loss and grief which is a good jumping point of playing Tim Drake , in under the dome his character was more like a genius and reserved which is a great reason to see him play the most intelligent detective in the world also in we bought a zoo he was more reckless , emotional and hopless which is similar to Tim drake , in Under the dome he was optimistic , lovely and caring to his friends much like Tim he was more badass as Sam and had shown some Physical work but he needs more training in martial arts and a stunt double , he could certainly work with Ben Affleck and rock the chemistry father -son with him he just his hair dyed to black i don’t care about the hair also he can totally pull over Leading abilities due to his roles in Supernatural
    he was such a mature , emotional and badass character like Tim should be , in disconnect he was more than troubled boy who had problems with his father and uses bullying as his own way to control his grief and anger which would totally work if DC/WB uses the 52 version of Tim Drake
    as for Harvey Dent i suggest Matt Damon he’s close to Ben Affleck age and he is a big name that i want in the DCEU the reason why he is better as Harvey Dent more than Hush is his role in both Bourne triology and the informant where he a bipolar conman and pulled crazy off very well which would totally could work for a villian like Harvey Dent also his role in Dogma was pretty similar to Harvey Dent he had also worked with Ben Affleck in it and it’s very nice to see them together in the DCEU again he had also the action sequences so i think it should work fine for Harvey Dent i do think he is the best choice
    sorry for the long text usually when i am suggesting a choice i explain why he/she is suited for the role it’s just a hobby i also wanna thank you for the advise i am currently having problems in the college because of the traveling thing

  2. Possibles for Tim Drake: Ryan Potter, Logan Lerman, Dylan O’Brien, Chandler Riggs, Josh Hutcherson, Colin Ford, or Asa Butterfield

  3. I personally really like Gigi Hadid as Stephanie Brown. I don’t know why. Plus, her and Dylan O’Brien look really cute. ( Who I’ve grown really used to being Tim Drake to me there can be no one else. Except for maybe Vini Uehara or Ryan Potter lol. ) + She’s a person of color so that’s a plus. Kiko Mizuhara is my Cassandra Cain, Aramis Knight is my Damian Wayne, Bob Morley is my Dick Grayson and Matthew Daddario (or maybe tyler posey) is my Jason Todd, Morena Baccarin is my Selina Kyle, Jane Levy is my Barbara Gordon. ( I think, lol. Babs is so hard to cast for me. ) You probably don’t care though. I’ve been rambling. Lol.

  4. […] Other surprising news in the DCE-Batman-U is a Nightwing film is under way. And WB is looking at The Lego Batman Movie director, Chris McKay, to helm the film with Bill Dubuque (The Accountant) writing the script. It certainly seems like McKay is up for it, given his Twitter feed. The question is, then, who will play Dick Grayson? I have a theory that heavily rumored DCEU-cast Armie Hammer could be Dick. He’s in the right age range, he’s got the right physical attributes, and the fact that he has ties to the DCEU only because of Geoff Johns and Joe Manganiello (Johns a co-writer for The Batman, Manganiello is Deathstroke)…But that’s just a theory. Who would you cast? […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s